Here I will display my reasons for and against each version of my “Cheater” narrative. And why I have decided on a version.
Version 1:
This was the first draft for my idea, so it definitely needed developing. So I did in the later versions. But I thought I should document this version anyway, so my creative process is visible.
I will not use this version of the narrative because it is too short, and only having one or two flashbacks does not create enough time to raise the tense atmosphere in the film. And I realized after this, that I should keep the confirmation of the dilemma ambiguous to the end.
Version 2:
To improve and develop my narrative from the last version, I knew that I had to strengthen the dilemma to make the situation more difficult to solve. At first, I thought giving Riley and Kyle a romantic history would be a good way to do this. But then I realized that I only have 10 minutes max to execute the film, so I thought that I should give them a history that could be conveyed in a short time. So then I came to the conclusion that making Kyle and Riley siblings would do the trick effectively. So I decided to leave this fact till the very end and execute it in a single line of dialogue. Having this line occur at the very end will make the audience have to decide on their own, what happened next?
Although this version will be significantly more difficult, with needing to get extras and make a party scene. I think it will be worth it because the flashbacks are intriguing and I will be able to control the Lighting, experimenting with Low-Key techniques that I have learned.
Version 3:
Although this idea is significantly similar to version 2, in terms of the present day scenes. I do not like it. And my dislike for this version comes from the lack of interest I have(and what the viewer would probably have) for the flashback scenes. Not much is happening in them, and they lack narrative significance. I also dont like this because if these scenes are outdoors, I am extremely limited on the control I have over the Lighting.
I will not be doing this idea.
Why version 2?:
I will be filming version 2 for numerous reasons:
- I think it is the best version out of the 3 I made up.
- It is more effective than version 1 due to the ambiguity of the situation.
- The flashback scenes are more interesting than version 2 because there is more stuff happening in the scenes.
- I can use Low-Key Lighting in the flashback scenes.
- I said in my pitch that I would like to improve my directing skills, and I think that putting myself into a situation where I need to direct a larger group of actors than usual, this will improve my directing skills. I have also wrote my script in a way that requires good acting to pull it off, this will be down to me as a director to achieve this level of emotion that I am demanding.
Why choose this base narrative?:
- People can relate to either 3 of these characters.
- I can develop my Sound design, Lighting, and Editing skills.
- The non-linear structure makes the narrative, which some would say is cliche, more interesting to a wider audience.
- Leaving the ending without a resolution, gives the film a thought-provoking effect. Which is something that I have mentioned in my initial pitch.